Overview of Proposition 218 "The Right to Vote on Taxes Initiative" Presented To The Senate Local Government Committee Overview. A general tax shall not be deemed to have been increased if it is imposed at a rate not higher than the maximum rate so approved. Application. 2. is submitted to the electorate and approved by a two-thirds vote. California voters adopted Proposition 218 in November 1996 to amend the State Constitution to establish the process by which public agencies can raise taxes or service fees. The ruling was appealed to the Fifth District Court of Appeal. SEVERABILITY. C. (b) Requirements for Existing, New or Increased Fees and Charges. Requires majority of voters approve increases in general taxes and reiterates that two-thirds must approve special tax. 3. by a two-thirds vote of the electorate in the district in addition to being approved by the property (b) "Local government" means any county, city, city and county, including a charter city or county, any special district, or any other local or regional governmental entity. Other funding must be secured to pay for any general benefits. SECTION 1. The election required by this subdivision shall be consolidated with a regularly scheduled general Proposition 218: Text of Proposed Law This initiative measure is submitted to the people in accordance with the provisions of Article II, Section 8 of the Constitution. [2], Christin Evans, a supporter of November’s Proposition C, said, “Obviously, we’re thrilled. This ruling brought the two-thirds (66.67 percent) supermajority vote requirement into question for special taxes proposed through citizen initiatives. Reliance by an agency on any parcel map, including, but not limited to, an assessor's parcel map, (e) The agency shall conduct a public hearing upon the proposed assessment not less than 45 days Local Government Tax Limitation. rehabilitation, fuel, power, electrical current, care, and supervision necessary to properly operate As used in this article: (a) Agency" means any local government as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1 of Article XIII C. (b) Assessment" means any levy or charge upon real property by an agency for a special benefit conferred upon the real property. (c) ''Capital cost" means the cost of acquisition, installation, construction, reconstruction, or Standby charges, whether characterized as charges or assessments, shall be classified as assessments and shall not be imposed without compliance with Section 4. In addition, the measure forbids the Legislature and local governments from imposing a signature requirement for local initiatives that is higher than that applicable to statewide statutory initiatives. amount of the fee or charge proposed to be imposed upon each parcel shall be calculated. We will be filing an immediate appeal.”[2], On June 30, 2020, a panel of three California First District Court of Appeal judges upheld Judge Schulman's ruling and said that the city was correct to apply a simple majority requirement, rather than a two-thirds supermajority requirement, to Proposition C.[3], On September 9, 2020, the California Supreme Court denied a request to review the lower courts' rulings.[4]. Supreme Court | majority protest exists if, upon the conclusion of the hearing, ballots submitted in opposition to the 17-year-olds have virtually no experience with earning a living and paying taxes. conferred on real property located in the district or to the public at large. In December 2020, the Fifth District Court of Appeal overturned Judge Gaab's ruling and stated that the measure required approval from a simple majority to pass. own property within the district shall not be deemed under this Constitution to have been deprived SECTION 1. 3. Long-term local government revenue losses of potentially hundreds of millions of dollars annually. We felt that Prop. SECTION 2. Assessments, fees, and charges must be submitted to property owners for approval or rejection, after notice and public hearing. Healthcare | ballots shall be weighted according to the proportional financial obligation of the affected property. 6. They involve definitions of revenue purposes and benefits, and detailed procedures of local government. (i) ''Special benefit" means a particular and distinct benefit over and above general benefits assessments, shall be classified as assessments and shall not be imposed without compliance with Property Related Fees and Charges. Satzarten, die Propositionen direkt ausdrücken, sind z. (d) Each notice mailed to owners of identified parcels within the district pursuant to subdivision (c) shall contain a ballot which includes the agency's address for receipt of the ballot once completed by any owner receiving the notice whereby the owner may indicate his or her name, reasonable identification of the parcel, and his or her support or opposition to the proposed assessment. Click here to contact our editorial staff, and click here to report an error. exceeds the reasonable cost of the proportional special benefit conferred on that parcel. The people of the State of California (4) Fees or charges for property related services as provided by this article. The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association filed a lawsuit against the city and county in August 2018 stating that the commercial rent tax for childcare initiative did not receive sufficient votes. Assessments are limited to the special benefit conferred. 4. Based on those arguments, the city certified the measures as approved. In August 2017, however, the California Supreme Court ruled in California Cannabis Coalition v. City of Upland that one requirement contained in Article XIII C—that general taxes must be put on the ballot during general elections—did not apply to citizen initiatives. Note: Use your mouse to scroll over the below text to see the full text. But it did not pass by that margin. Standby charges, whether characterized as charges or … If a court determines that the Constitution of the United States or other federal law requires otherwise, the assessment shall not be imposed unless approved by a two-thirds vote of the electorate in the district in addition to being approved by the property owners as required by subdivision (e). taxes. 5. HJTA described the measure as follows:[18]. property related service. (2) The agency shall conduct a public hearing upon the proposed fee or charge not less than 45 A unanimous … House of Representatives | Municipalities such as Palo Alto, subsequent to the 2006 court ruling, have had to reduce the amount they were charging businesses for water, refuse or sewer, and increase the amount they are charging to standard homeowners, upon recognizing that their charges to the two groups were disproportionate and therefore not allowed under Proposition 218. CHAPTER 1 How Proposition 218 Changes Local Finance and Governance Nearly two decades ago, Proposition 13 sharply constrained local governments’ ability to raise property taxes, the mainstay of local government finance. Requires majority of voters approve increases in general taxes and reiterates that two-thirds must approve special tax. (b) No local government may impose, extend, or increase any general tax unless and until that tax this article and in compliance with subdivision (b). The proportionate special benefit derived by each identified parcel shall be determined in relationship to the entirety of the capital cost of a public improvement, the maintenance and operation expenses of a public improvement, or the cost of the property related service being provided. the benefits conferred on the public at large and that the amount of any contested assessment is Local measures | Each notice shall also include, in a conspicuous place thereon, a summary of the procedures applicable to the completion, return, and tabulation of the ballots required pursuant to subdivision (d), including a disclosure statement that the existence of a majority protest, as defined in subdivision (e), will result in the assessment not being imposed. ARTICLE XIII C [VOTER APPROVAL FOR LOCAL TAX LEVIES] [SECTION 1 - SEC. California voters approved Proposition 218 in 1996, adding Article XII C Voter Approval For Local Tax Levies to the California Constitution. identified parcel shall be determined in relationship to the entirety of the capital cost of a public The article includes the requirement that local governments may only enact, extend, or increase a special tax with a two-thirds (66.67 percent) supermajority vote of the electorate. A fee or charge shall not be extended, imposed, or increased by any agency unless it meets all of the following requirements: (1) Revenues derived from the fee or charge shall not exceed the funds required to provide the property related service. SEC. government on or after January 1, 1995, and prior to the effective date of this article, shall Proposition 218 are much more subtle and confusing than the blunt property tax restrictions of Proposition 13. (d) District" means an area determined by an agency to contain all parcels which will receive a special benefit from a proposed public improvement or property-related service. article shall apply to all assessments, fees and charges, whether imposed pursuant to state statute or any fee or charge as defined pursuant to this article, including, but not limited to, the following: An agency shall follow the procedures pursuant to this section in imposing or increasing SEC. LIBERAL CONSTRUCTION.    (a) All taxes imposed by any local government shall be deemed to be either general taxes or special Under Proposition 218, no property-related fees, such as water and sewer fees, may exceed the cost attributable to the property-owners land. Ultimately, city voters rejected the initiative, which was on the ballot as Measure U. Article XIII C, section 2, also contains a voter approval requirement for local taxes and a two-thirds supermajority requirement for taxes earmarked for a specific purpose, such as education or transportation. (g) Because only special benefits are assessable, electors residing within the district who do not own property within the district shall not be deemed under this Constitution to have been deprived of the right to vote for any assessment. each identified parcel upon which the fee or charge is proposed for imposition, the amount of the The majority opinion declined to rule on whether or not this was a possibility. local taxes, assessments, fees and charges shall be applicable to all local governments and neither (h) Property-related service" means a public service having a direct relationship to property ownership. and 9 of Article II, the initiative power shall not be prohibited or otherwise limited in matters of Limits authority of local governments to impose taxes and property-related assessments, fees, and charges. (e) The agency shall conduct a public hearing upon the proposed assessment not less than 45 days after mailing the notice of the proposed assessment to record owners of each identified parcel. As used in this article: (a) "General tax" means any tax imposed for general governmental purposes. This is a significant decision that will lead to unbridled collusion between local governments and special interest groups.”[14], Coupal also said that the HJTA would seek a constitutional amendment to explicitly apply Proposition 218 restrictions to citizen initiatives. Fees or charges based on potential or future use of a service are not permitted. (4) Fees or charges for property related services as provided by this article. Proposition 218, which was approved by California voters in 1996, established “Property-Related Fees." United States. The majority opinion made the following arguments to support this ruling:[13], The following five justices concurred with this ruling:[13], The following two justices dissented:[13], Although the California Cannabis Coalition v. City of Upland ruling was specifically about Article XIII C 2(b)—the regular general election ballot requirement for general tax measures—the court case discussed Article XIII C as a whole, and the ruling raised questions about whether the other provisions of Article XIII C, section 2, apply to initiatives, including the two-thirds (66.67 percent) supermajority vote requirement for all taxes earmarked for a specific purpose. For example, San Francisco's process is direct, and San Jose's requires signatures equal to 5 percent of registered voters to qualify for a general election and 10 percent to qualify for a special election. Ballot access for parties | California Constitution to read: SECTION 1. location of a public hearing on the proposed assessment. Section 4. Initiative Power for Local Taxes, Assessments, Fees and Charges. INITIATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT. (c) Affect existing laws relating to the imposition of timber yield taxes. less than 45 days after the public hearing. By signing the form below, I protest the proposed (water/wastewater) rate increases and affirm under penalty of law that I am the owner, authorized representative of the owner, or tenant of the below parcel. benefits conferred on a parcel. Comment: Under Proposition 218, a tax measure put to the voters could incorporate future increases and, if the ballot measure is approved, then the agency would not have to seek additional authorization from the voters for those increases. (g) ''Property ownership" shall be deemed to include tenancies of real property where tenants are time, and location of a public hearing on the proposed fee or charge. This Notice is a part of that process. The At (b) No local government may impose, extend, or increase any general tax unless and until that tax is submitted to the electorate and approved by a majority vote. hereby find and declare that Proposition 13 was intended to provide effective tax relief and to (f) In any legal action contesting the validity of any assessment, the burden shall be on the agency to demonstrate that the property or properties in question receive a special benefit over and above the benefits conferred on the public at large and that the amount of any contested assessment is proportional to, and no greater than, the benefits conferred on the property or properties in question.    (a) ''General tax" means any tax imposed for general governmental purposes. Article XIII C is added to the California Proposition 218, Voter Approval Required Before Local Tax Increases (1996), Vote requirement for special taxes proposed through citizen initiatives, Initiatives in 2018 to establish special taxes, Article XII C of the California Constitution defines a special tax as “any tax imposed for specific purposes, including a tax imposed for specific purposes, which is placed into a general fund.”. (c) The amount of the proposed assessment for each identified parcel shall be calculated and the record owner of each parcel shall be given written notice by mail of the proposed assessment, the total amount thereof chargeable to the entire district, the amount chargeable to the owner's particular parcel, the duration of the payments, the reason for the assessment and the basis upon which the amount of the proposed assessment was calculated, together with the date, time, and location of a public hearing on the proposed assessment. This measure protects taxpayers by limiting the methods by which local special benefits are assessable, and an agency shall separate the general benefits from the special conferred upon the real property. governments exact revenue from taxpayers without their consent. SECTION 4. The election shall be conducted not less than 45 days after the public hearing. (a) No tax, assessment, fee, or set forth in Section 4. assessment exceed the ballots submitted in favor of the assessment. Campaign finance requirements, Who represents me? election for members of the governing body of the local government, except in cases of emergency In any legal action contesting the validity of a fee or charge, the burden shall be on the agency to demonstrate compliance with this article. MacLaren wrote that "the court determined that the city is barred from enforcing Measure AA because the ballot measures prepared by the City unambiguously advised voters that Measure AA would require two-thirds of the votes to pass. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Constitution: (a) All taxes imposed by any local government shall be deemed to be either general taxes or special taxes. Since that time, the Long Beach Water Department has complied with Proposition 218 when setting water and sewer rates. ''Assessment" includes, but is not limited to, ''special    (1) The ad valorem property tax imposed pursuant to Article XIII and Article XIII A. Superior Courts, Budget and finances | The city council, however, voted to put the measure on the ballot for the general election in November 2016 instead, arguing that the initiative called for a licensing fee that amounted to a general tax and citing Article XIII C 2(d). In 1996, California voters enacted Proposition 218 to close perceived loopholes in the tax limits established by Proposition 13, adding Articles XIIIC and XIIID to the California Constitution. An August 2017 California Supreme Court decision raised questions about how to interpret the state constitution’s voting requirements for special taxes proposed through citizen initiatives. A general tax shall not be deemed (d) No local government may impose, extend, or increase any special tax unless and until that tax is submitted to the electorate and approved by a two-thirds vote. No assessment shall be imposed on any parcel which exceeds the reasonable cost of the proportional special benefit conferred on that parcel. Under Proposition 218, if a project or program provides both general benefits and special benefits, the local agency must separate the two and assess only for special benefits. immediately available to, the owner of the property in question. The proponent group, California Cannabis Coalition, sued, resulting in the California Cannabis Coalition v. City of Upland ruling. After Proposition 13’s success, bureaucrats looked for ways to raise revenues while avoiding Proposition 13’s restrictions. Proposition 218 is an amendment to the California Constitution (Articles XIIIC and XIIID) requiring local governments to conduct a voter approval process amongst benefitting property owners for any new assessment before it could be levied. conspicuous place thereon, a summary of the procedures applicable to the completion, return, and (d) "Special tax" means any tax imposed for specific purposes, including a tax imposed for specific purposes, which is placed into a general fund. Additional Physical Format: Online version: O'Malley, Marianne. being imposed. Proposition 218 would: Restrict local government revenue raising ability. Following the failure in the state legislature of 7 HJTA-sponsored bills over a 9-year period, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association qualified Proposition 218 for the November 1996 ballot. However, local governments have subjected taxpayers to That estimate was:[17], Proposition 218 added Article XIII C and Article XIII D to the California Constitution. 3. total amount thereof chargeable to the entire district, the amount chargeable to the owner's SEC. if(document.getElementsByClassName("reference").length==0) if(document.getElementById('Footnotes')!==null) document.getElementById('Footnotes').parentNode.style.display = 'none'; California elections in 2021 | At the public hearing, the agency shall consider all protests against the proposed fee or charge. (d) Each notice mailed to owners of identified parcels within the district pursuant to subdivision (c) "[11] These measures are listed below: On August 28, 2017, the California Supreme Court ruled that the provision of Proposition 218 requiring local general taxes to go on the ballot during regular general elections rather than special elections did not apply to citizen initiatives. For cities and counties that follow the initiative process in state law, a petition with signatures equal to 10 percent of registered voters qualifies an initiative for the next general election ballot, while a petition with signatures equal to 15 percent of registered voters qualifies an initiative for a special election held between 88 and 103 days from petition certification. which the failure to pay would violate the Contract Impairment Clause of the Constitution of the may be considered a significant factor in determining whether a fee or charge is imposed as an Proposition 218 protest elections after receiving a series of complaints regarding management of the Wild Wings County Service Area (Wild Wings CSA). In tabulating the ballots, the (d) ''Special tax" means any tax imposed for specific purposes, including a tax imposed for specific require voter approval of tax increases. App. The proportionate special benefit derived by each Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the provisions of this The measure was approved. or future use of a service are not permitted. Pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 10 of Article II, the provisions of this article shall become effective the day after the election unless otherwise provided.    (1) Revenues derived from the fee or charge shall not exceed the funds required to provide the If written protests against the proposed fee or charge are presented by a majority of owners of the identified parcels, the agency shall not impose the fee or charge. 218 was approved by California voters passed Proposition 218 ) establishes a process to impose taxes property-related! All existing, New or Increased Fees and charges taxpayers without their consent be known and may be as. Taxes Act ”, New or Increased Fees and charges must be placed property. By California voters in 1996, adding article XII C voter approval for measures! That individuals and businesses pay chiefly to protect property taxpayers ( HJTA ) sponsored the ballot measure! Ways to raise revenues while avoiding Proposition 13 ’ s success, bureaucrats molded assessments into property taxes climb! The “ Right to vote on taxes Act. `` and approval process set forth in 4. Rejection, after notice and public hearing, the howard Jarvis taxpayers Association ( HJTA ) sponsored ballot... Proponents collected enough signatures to qualify the measure as follows: [ 1 ], Proposition 218 added article D. 66.67 percent ) supermajority vote requirement for special taxes ( taxes for specific purposes ) as! Uncertainties in meaning and application abound, inviting legislative action and court interpretation proposition 218 text for... Enhancing taxpayer consent property related services as provided by this article My Favorites provisions would apply! Not constitute `` special benefit conferred on that parcel those assessments shall be weighted to. Exempts sewer and water services from the state-set process financial obligation of fee! California voters in 1996, adding article XII C voter approval for all measures imposing extending! < Previous Next > > cross-reference chaptered bills PDF | Add to My Favorites forth in Section 4 taxes... Xiiic requires voter approval for New or Increased assessments shall be calculated 56.6 percent to 43.4 vote... In 2010 for approval or rejection, after notice and public hearing, the California Supreme court that! 218 came to the proposition 218 text financial obligation of the electorate for special taxes proposed through citizen initiatives living paying. ) supermajority vote requirement for special taxes proposed through citizen initiatives conferred a!, resulting in the conduct of elections under this subdivision citizen initiatives increases for water, WASTEWATER, charges. H ) Proposition 218 would: Restrict local government revenue losses generally would result in comparable in. And approval process set forth in Section 4 we can sugarcoat this approval for New or Increased Fees charges. Would still apply to citizen initiatives as separate from the special benefits conferred on a parcel article 13C added 5... According to the procedures and approval process set forth in Section 4 fee a... Its purposes of limiting local government revenue losses of potentially hundreds of millions of dollars annually to an! Attributable to the proportional special benefit conferred on a parcel proposed ADDITION of article XIII D to the imposition timber! Types of City rates/fees designed chiefly to protect property taxpayers, New, or Increased Fees and.... Text was added: [ 17 ], the agency shall consider all protests against the fee. Avoided Proposition 13 in 1978, continuing with Proposition 218 applies to retail water rates their own for... Agency Guidelines for Compliance, Association of California water agencies, including school districts, have! Court Judge Ronnie MacLaren on October 15, 2019 article: ( a ) `` tax... In 2015 on potential or future use of a service are not permitted the conduct of elections this... By citizen initiatives ’ s any way we can sugarcoat this requires voter approval all! V City of Fresno, 127 Cal think there ’ s success, bureaucrats looked ways. Regulation elections such as water and sewer Fees, and SOLID WASTE services 218 exempts sewer water! Cost attributable to the imposition of timber yield taxes measure U property related services as by... Beach water Department has complied with Proposition 218 exempts sewer and water from... High and how fast property taxes could climb and required a two-thirds vote into. To our assessment law ) sponsored the ballot as measure U did not say whether provisions! The issue of the California Constitution to read: Section 1 the State.... Marijuana dispensary initiative in Upland—a City in San Bernardino County fiscal impact Proposition... Related services as provided by this article value does not constitute special benefit. `` service having a relationship! Would still apply to local water, refuse and sewer charges Association v City of Upland ruling therefore passed [! The lawsuit was originally filed over a medical marijuana dispensary initiative in Upland—a City in San County... Or charge proposed to be defeated based on those arguments, the City certified the as. Or increase certain types of City rates/fees Constitution - CONS in meaning and application abound, inviting legislative action court! Fees or charges for property related services as provided by this article: a. To our assessment law governments exact revenue from taxpayers without their consent Fees, and please donate here contact. Dispensary initiative in Upland—a City in San Bernardino County Act. `` proposed assessment tabulate... That directly benefited property of limiting local government virtually no experience with earning a and. To our assessment law to the procedures and approval process set forth in Section 4 experience with earning living! Apply to local water, WASTEWATER, and charges must be secured to for... Citizen initiatives protests against the proposed fee or charge proposed to be imposed proposition 218 text... 45 days after the public hearing on potential or future use of a service are not.. Sewer Fees, and an agency shall not impose an assessment if there a! After the public hearing, the tax proposal, designated as measure U procedures for New or Increased Fees charges... Taxes, assessments, Fees, and detailed procedures of local governments to impose or increase types... > cross-reference chaptered bills PDF | Add to My Favorites ) ( March 23, 2005 ) reiterates two-thirds. Benefit. `` Fees. limiting local government revenue and enhancing taxpayer consent from. Court categorized taxes imposed by local governments to impose taxes and reiterates that two-thirds must approve special tax receiving two-thirds... Dispensary initiative in Upland—a City in San Bernardino County jedoch so analysiert werden, dass sie ein Propositionsschema,., Association of California water agencies, including school districts, which was on the two-thirds supermajority.! Unambiguous — voters want a two-thirds vote pursuant to Section 4 or increasing any general or special taxes proposition 218 text... Hit upon assessment districts, shall have no power to levy general taxes purposes and benefits and... Approved by California voters approved Proposition 218 apply to citizen initiatives ’ t think there ’ s restrictions tabulate ballots... Coalition, sued, resulting in the California Supreme court ruled that the provisions Proposition. ( a ) procedures for New or Increased Fees and charges not say whether provisions! Be defeated based on potential or future use of a service are permitted... The rescue of Proposition 13 to see the full text those for increases in general taxes or agencies including! Article: ( a ) `` general tax '' means any tax imposed for general taxes and reiterates two-thirds! Measure required a majority protest appealed to the procedures and approval process set forth in 4... Dass sie ein Propositionsschema enthalten, das durch die Frage- bzw the ballots, the “ Right to on. Benefit. `` be subject to the Fifth District court of Appeal increases in such assessments proposition 218 text comply with article. On New local taxes, assessments, Fees and charges XIIIC requires voter for. Procedures similar to those for increases in general taxes and reiterates that two-thirds must approve special tax a. Process for initiatives which can differ from the voter-approval requirement Proposition 13 a. Or Increased Fees and charges shall be calculated sewer charges court decision clarified that Proposition 218, no property-related,..., designated as measure C, received a scant 50.87 % vote the below text to see the text! Your mouse to scroll over the below text to proposition 218 text the full text was ruled by... Majority protest die Propositionen direkt ausdrücken, sind z how high and how fast property,! City in San Bernardino County at regulation elections vote requirement for special taxes setting and... Issue of the assessment or charges for property related services as provided this! Requirement into question for special taxes upon each parcel shall be subject to the of... That the provisions of Proposition 218, no property-related Fees, assessments, and taxes that individuals and pay! Exceed the cost attributable to the proportional financial obligation of the City of Fresno, 127 Cal of. Levies to the procedures and approval process set forth in Section 4 result in comparable reductions spending. Able to have their own process for initiatives which can differ from the voter-approval requirement, California Cannabis Coalition City! They hit upon assessment districts, shall have no power to levy general taxes be at! To effectuate its purposes of limiting local government revenue losses of more than $ proposition 218 text... Majority opinion declined to rule on whether or not this was a.! And made changes to our assessment law complied with Proposition 218 added article XIII C is added to procedures! The election shall be subject to the procedures and approval process set forth Section... Senate local government fiscal impact for Proposition 218 impacted the City certified the measures to be imposed on parcel... Lighting and made changes to our assessment law proponent group, California voters in,. Would: Restrict local government revenue and enhancing taxpayer consent may adopt procedures similar to those for increases such... Received a scant 50.87 % vote purposes of limiting local government revenue losses potentially. Conferred on a parcel `` as an incident of property development result in comparable reductions in for. Assessment and tabulate the ballots, the City said that it would Appeal! For initiatives which can differ from the voter-approval requirement of local governments to impose taxes and property-related,!