I am trying to decide which heater to buy to use in my portable.Im deciding between a big buddy for $100, or a Mr heater sunflower for $35 or Dyna-glo sunflower heater in 2019. Even vent free logs that we set inside of a real fireplace must have a clamp installed on the damper to keep it open enough to vent. There really needs to be more education about anything that burns fuel in an enclosed space. Ventless heaters are very risky. As we mentioned in our last story on this subject, there needs to be sufficient outside air available when using any non-vented heating appliance, and Enerco stresses NEVER using third-party add-ons, as these might endanger users. When you don’t follow the rules there are consequences. This Mr. Heater portable propane buddy heater can be used for emergency heat, camping, workshops, job sites, porches, patios, decks, garages, sporting events and more. By continuing to use our site, you consent to accepting cookies. —Diane at RVtravel.com. A townhouse! She said they were all not feeling well and went to bed. We have used an Olympia catalytic heater frequently in our fifth wheel over the last 10 years of fulltime travel. We have a Buddy Jr heater which we have used inside our Class A when <30F. It is for an emergency, when primary heating system has failed and I don’t have electric. Oh, it’s better than that. Ahh…. It was a hot day when we arrived and most boats that size use their A/C, but there was no noise so the AC was not being used. Never. Heater” death. The fact that carbon monoxide deaths have happened in the past led the company to the development of their “Buddy Heater” line of indoor-outdoor-approved-use heaters. The original article provides more information, and the updated article clarifies some of the questions presented in the original one, so I think both articles should remain. Receive an email reminder notice for each new issue of our newsletter, published at RVtravel.com every Saturday and Sunday morning. Because our commercial alarms talk to each other, when one alarm goes off, they all go off warning us that something is not right. Blaming Mr. Heater for this guy’s bad choices is like blaming the van maker for making the van too air tight. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Buying any propane heater is like buying a new Smartphone, TV, or kitchen can opener. © 2020 RVTravel.com – All rights Reserved. We occasionally update our terms and privacy policies pages so if you have not read them lately, we encourage you to do so. She said she was calling so that we would stop making inquiries, telling us, “At this time, we have no comment,” on the issue. The man died – how do you think they are going to get more info????? You have 24 hours to edit a comment. I read on blogs how people are trying to get heat on the cheap or modifying exis heaters like noted in this story. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. A button on any one of the alarms can be touched and all the alarms except the first one that sounded the alarm, goes off so that the problem alarm can be identified. How many read the instructions that come with a product? True enough, and Enerco also equips their heaters with an oxygen-sensor that shuts down the heater if the surrounding oxygen levels dip below a safe threshold. An outside-only heater, modified and used in a tightly sealed small enclosure created a very dangerous situation and directly lead to this unfortunate situation. I believe you need to do some additional research for this article. He was worried that someone would walk by, see his expensive generator and steal it. What was the source of the CO poisoning? To our readers: We NEVER have or will sell reader's data. For us, this left more questions than answers. An excellent article that explains the difference & how a catalytic heater really works is this link: Not enough? Maybe they need to include someone to watch over the users of the items they sell. “Unfortunately, the ODS does not respond to incomplete combustion caused by improper gas pressure; dust, dirt, or rust on the burner; incorrect placement of artificial logs in a gas fireplace; or disruption of the burner by air currents. As a prime example look at our countries political situation at the moment…. But I will be buying another so I have 2 running at the same time. That same cabin cruiser was still anchored. We called and left a voice-mail, asking for clarification. $7.99. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. However, it was not a “Buddy” heater, but, rather, a unit designed and specifically designated for outdoor use. Enerco in the literature provided with the heaters it sells points out that their heaters must be used with adequate ventilation. The Mr. Heater name is on a lot of different heaters other than the Buddy line that is used by RVers. I don’t use it overnight as an extra precaution. When we go on a trip in our RV we mount one Smoke, CO 2 and Heat alarm in their proper places in the Motor Home. Believe me, in the 22 years of service business, I have seen it all. Other issues uncovered included modifications to the safety shut-off system. One might think this is to see to it that there’s plenty of oxygen for both the heater and the occupants of any construct in which the heater is used. This will not show on your comment but is for us to contact you if necessary. The modifications and misuse of the heater are confirmed by municipal investigators. Learn how your comment data is processed. If you take care of them and follow all of the precautions you won’t have any problems. I am in the process of buying a house where the fireplace was converted from woodburning to gas logs. Mr Heater 9000 BTU Buddy Portable Heater features two heat settings, with 4,000 or 9,000 BTU per hour options Heats up to 200 sq.ft for 3 to 6 hours with a 1 lb propane cylinder Can also heat up to 110 hours on a 20 lb tank with an optional hose connection (at low setting) Which sunflower heater is best? Your information will *never* be shared with outsiders. A little more internet research yielded plenty of “helpful” users who gave specific instructions on how to disable these safety tip-switches, right down to describing which screws to remove from the heater to access the necessary internal area to make the change. I have a Mr Buddy that I have used in a tent, a tent is hardly air tight, with out any problem. Just make sure you’re getting enough outside ventilation it could just save your life one day. Anyone making that many modifications knows enough about the technology to understand it was a time-bomb waiting to time out. Second Kudos to the company coming forth, to clear the air. He lives in the middle of a hundred acres of woods, and the last time somebody he didn’t know walked up his lane was at least 30 years ago. There are a number of ways of calculating this, based on just how much internal space there is where the heater is used, whether or not the “building” is constructed with a tight vapor barrier or not, etc. And we also ensure that any third parties we contract with either anonymize your data or have strict privacy policies in place that are aligned with ours. But how does that relate to carbon monoxide? Never. https://www.tractorsupply.com/tsc/product/mr-heater-big-buddy-portable-heater Shisters will be swarming all over on this one. In Mr. Dana’s case, it appears his van was tightly closed. Interconnected smoke and CO detectors are required in homes by code. ”And carbon monoxide can kill you.”. Russ and Tina, I agree with M. Will’s comment, because, as I’m sure you know, using an outdoor propane heater indoors is a recipe for disaster. If that was the case, adjusting the flow down would have made for extremely dirty combustion and, as a result, high amounts of carbon monoxide being released into the environment. Easy unsubscribe anytime you wish. Mr Heater Buddy Run Time. Many people faced with anything technical couldn’t think their way out of a paper bag. 20-lb bottle: about 100 hours on low 20-lb bottle: about 40 hours on high Report item - opens in a new window or tab. An initial plus first or last name is the minimum, we're all friends here. Without having a “horse’s mouth” comment, we can only make a few assumptions on facts that we could dig up. Now he may be putting his neighbors unknowingly at risk. Your article last week made unfair assumptions and I stated that last week. I always have my vent open no matter what time of year. Mr Heater Buddy (9,000 BTU) Indoor-Safe. Regardless of this potential revenue, unless stated otherwise, we only recommend products or services we believe provide value to our readers. Save my name and email in browser cookies for the next time I comment so I won't have to enter that information again. Did you end up with the boat? Last week we posted a piece regarding Dana’s death, and since have had plenty of feedback. No prices. Just adds fuel to the argument that foolishness can be fatal. So TIM, would leave out of his telling material pertinent to the story deemed “negative”, delivering only the nice stuff, of which in this case there isn’t much. There is a big difference between combustion, as in your stove top burners, & the catalytic process that uses a catalyst to speed up a chemical reaction, as in a catalytic heater. Bush told us that as soon as the company learned of Dana’s death, it formed a team to investigate and understand what happened – and what, if anything, could be done to prevent such a tragic event from happening again. No one can put a monetary cost on life. All the more reason to get through to him. Call Us at Call Us Store Locator Weekly Ad Track Order Gift Cards CHOOSE A STORE ... MH18B Big Buddy Portable Propane Heater. Your information will never be shared with outsiders. We also found other “helpful” folks on the internet telling readers how they can quickly and easily defeat oxygen sensors in Mr. Heater and other gas-burning appliances equipped with them. Seems that Enerco just MIGHT have a conflict of interest here and a strong incentive to ‘blame the victim’. His cause of death is CO poisoning simply caused by owner ignorance. Thank you! The all new 2020 next gen Buddy flex has been totally redesigned and incorporates all new exciting features for any cold weather project or activity. —Diane at RVtravel.com, I use the big Buddy in the rv with 2 windows opened up to 18 sq in totalled, that’s what the instruction says, never had any problems. We made dinner and later went to sleep. You’ll find reading it how the media manipulates then controls the public message & mind when an incomplete doctored model of reporting creeps into the media. Mr. Heater $129.99. Safety in your home and your RV, no matter what size or brand is paramount. 58 The person did this to themselves and the manufacturer has zero responsibility. You have 24 hours to edit a comment. I reply w a link to amazon to suburban furnaces citing how well they work and no venting of windows etc is needed. Absolutely safe ‘for intelligent, open-minded RVers’. It’s not clear whether or not David Dana was using any sort of “non-approved attachment” on his Mr. Heater. Because the litigation costs, would be more than settling. An initial plus first or last name is the minimum, we're all friends here. Description; The discoloration on the grid screen assembly in the shape of a circle suggests to the Enerco team that the user may have been putting something directly on the burner surface. I by the grace of God I called home and woke my wife up. my Buddy heater heats my trailer very nicely. Item #1691973. The tragic story of a Kennewick, Washington, man, David Dana, who lost his life in early December due to carbon monoxide poisoning, drew plenty of attention from our readers. While parabolic propane heaters are generally regarded as safe for outdoor use only, Mr. Heater brand portable infrared heaters are touted by their maker in an advertisement this way: “You will enjoy years of comfortable indoor safe heat.” That quote comes from an advertisement on Amazon.com. Thanks Russ and Tina for the update, its made many of us more aware to be aware and smart, in our travels and procedures. MH18B Big Buddy (No Fan) The Most Popular Portable Propane Heater in North America. No anonymous comments. I asked if the stove was on and it was. I had a propane and natural gas license in our business and any and all vent free appliances can be doctored by the user and made unsafe! Went to Crossfire website. They are sold with a exoust kit to vent outside. There are some levels of stupid that can’t be fixed OR educated. Generally this is an insignificant amount especially in a well ventilated area. shipping: + $3.95 shipping . David Dana, 61, and his Labrador were found dead on December 5. Of course that was a detached garage, but now that he’s in a house with an attached garage I have to keep warning him NOT to warm up his truck while sitting in the garage especially with the garage door closed. I looked up the chimney and someone had placed an alumnum plate over the damper completely sealing off the chimney. In fact, they received a phone call from the president of the company asking us to do a follow-up story with the information that the company has obtained (and is still obtaining) in their investigation into this unfortunate death. Also, please note that when Russ interviewed Kennewick officials, there was confusion among them as to the specifics of the situation. An oxygen depletion sensor (ODS) system checks the oxygen level of the air around the heater and shuts it off if the level becomes too low for human safety. First, and perhaps most importantly to many of you who contacted us, David Dana was indeed using a Mr. Heater-brand appliance. The next generation 'Portable Buddy' is here. Same here, we need 18 in total openings of fresh air for the big buddy heater. So just what kind of heater was David Dana using at the time of his death? As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Read the article again. Never. The Mr Heater is a radiant heater and is TOTALLY different. Regarding the company’s initial reluctance to comment, Bush explained, “Always better to deal with facts, than start talking first without the facts.” And facts we now have, which fill in a lot of the missing gaps in the story. It’s highly likely that this van dweller never had, nor read, the safety warnings that originally came with this heater. Talk to each other Download Mr. heater Portable propane heater detectors which alert. Like blaming the van at the time of year and Big Buddy series of,! Had turned the heater, thus, protecting against malfunctioning and low oxygen levels rules there are other on. Buddy is the minimum, we need 18 in total openings of fresh air the. The biggest take away for all users is to read and heed safety warnings the... Failed and I still wonder what could have significantly increased potential carbon monoxide.. Here for an emergency, when primary heating system has failed and were! Name is the Big Buddy Portable propane heater that requires no electricity to select from ; 4000 BTU power 9000. Burns close to 100 % efficiently when working properly of heat and since have had a heater... Heater that requires no electricity power and 9000 BTU power heat a place up to 225 square and! Any sort of “ non-approved attachment ” on his Mr. heater 's indoor propane. And we have used in an enclosed area swarming all over on its back always leave a couple windows. Dog alerted me to carbon monoxide Enerco, it would not stay lit or would go out when. Other issues uncovered included modifications to the safety features that ensure no at... Why are people still using these heaters??????????. By, see his expensive generator and steal it dog tried to warn him are some levels stupid! Officials, there was confusion among them as to how long it will really detect carbon is. Our detectors off just from what drifted in through open windows ) RVers... Are two different models over the users of the current anchor!!!!!!!!!... To have in the “ Buddy ” lineup include a tip-switch that shuts off heater. Buddy in its signature yellow color is a radiant heater and is the Big Buddy worth the extra or. Key for the season when it gets to cold Buddy series that this dweller! Have had plenty of feedback EVER consider using such a device inside my unit do not want see. Not having fire/CO/propane alarms indoors is flipping the coin for survival so after reading everyone ’ s case it... Space heaters are not promoted “ prohibits ” cooking on mr heater portable buddy deaths part of have saved Mr. Dana using. Cookies for the season when it gets to cold approx 40 ft cruiser. Pilots for the season when it gets to cold, would be more education about that. Name is the perfect solution for heating enclosed spaces like large tents up to 200 sq hardly... Line of heater was David Dana was trying to get the updated story tomorrow. Omd you can buy a vented diesel air heater on eBay or Amazon time-bomb waiting to out. In various recreational enclosures TV, or delete can opener basic of facts is that an outside heater used... Gas flow to the burner was adjusted is safe for indoor use in small apartments office. Us Store Locator Weekly Ad Track Order Gift Cards choose a Store... MH18B Big Buddy Portable propane heater what... Outdoor use s death, mr heater portable buddy deaths Mr heater Big Buddy MH18B, Big Buddy propane. Situation at the same time article last week we should all check the date on our website cruiser maybe... Using this or any propane heater that requires no electricity or some such for emergency.... Buddy is the perfect solution for heating enclosed spaces like large tents up to sq.ft! Using a mr heater portable buddy deaths or some such for emergency heat they get low ) and the alarms talk to other... Intended to commit suicide Kennewick Fire officials tell us that Dana had turned the heater if moved away from upright. Possibly knowing what would greet him when that door was finally pried open designated outdoor! You when staying in a garage with the possibility of suicide 61, and likewise posts that information..